Angie’s List vs Yelp: Which Reviews Platform Is Right for You?

Last updated:

Are you considering hiring a service professional but not sure what platform to use to find reviews? Angie’s List and Yelp are two of the biggest names in the business, but they have differing approaches to verifying their reviews.

Angie’s List is a paid subscription-based service that vets its reviewers to ensure honest, trustworthy feedback. Yelp, on the other hand, is free to use but has faced criticism for fake reviews and for allegedly manipulating reviews based on whether or not businesses advertise with them.

With the rise of social media, Angie’s List has rebranded itself as “Angie’s List – Home Advisor,” leading many to wonder what the controversy is all about and whether it’s worth the cost. Others have even taken to Reddit to question if the platform is worth the investment.

But is there truly a need to pay for Angie’s List, or are there free alternatives? And how does it stack up against other popular review platforms like HomeAdvisor and Thumbtack?

In this blog post, we’ll explore the pros and cons of Angie’s List and Yelp, examine the controversy surrounding Angie’s List, and delve into other review platforms to help you determine which is best suited for your needs. Let’s dive in.

Angie’s List vs Yelp: Which One Is Best for Your Needs

If you’re looking for a reliable online review site for local services, you’re likely wondering whether Angie’s List or Yelp is a better option. Despite the two platforms sharing a similar mission, there are notable differences between them.

Angie’s List: A Membership-Based Review Site

Angie’s List is a membership-based online review site where users pay a monthly or yearly fee to access reviews of local service providers‌. This payment model is why Angie’s List tends to have more detailed and trustworthy reviews than Yelp, as the paywall keeps out fake or biased reviews.

The platform has over 6 million members and caters primarily to homeowners who want trusted reviews of household service providers such as plumbers, electricians, and lawn care companies. The site’s main advantage is that all reviews are curated by a team of experts, ensuring that members have access to reliable information.

Yelp: A Free-For-All Review Site

Yelp is a free, open review platform that has gained popularity in recent years. With over 200 million active monthly users and an average of 216 million monthly unique visitors, Yelp is one of the largest review platforms on the web. Unlike Angie’s List, Yelp is open to anyone, and users can leave reviews for businesses in almost any industry.

However, the downside of Yelp is that it lacks the curation and regulation present in Angie’s List, which can lead to unreliable reviews. Yelp has been plagued by fake reviews, and the site’s algorithm has struggled to identify and remove them.

The Verdict: It Depends on What You’re Looking For

So, which platform should you use? It ultimately comes down to your needs. If you’re primarily interested in household service providers and want trustworthy, well-curated reviews, Angie’s List is the way to go. However, if you’re looking for a broad range of businesses and don’t mind sifting through reviews to determine their legitimacy, Yelp is a solid option.

Whichever site you choose, be sure to take all reviews with a grain of salt and do your research before hiring any service provider. With due diligence and a bit of effort, you can use these platforms to make informed choices and get the most out of your local services.

Angie’s List Reddit: A Community of Opinions

If you’re looking for discussion and opinions on Angie’s List, there’s a subreddit dedicated to it. The Angie’s List subreddit is a community-driven forum that welcomes all opinions about the service. Here’s a brief look at what you’ll find when you visit the subreddit:

Discussions on Membership Costs and Benefits

One of the most popular topics on the Angie’s List subreddit is the cost of membership and the benefits you receive from it. Members and non-members alike can chime in with their opinions on whether or not the service is worth the cost. Some Redditors even offer tips on how to get the most out of your membership.

Personal Experiences with Contractors

Another popular topic on the subreddit is the quality of the contractors listed on Angie’s List. Members share their personal experiences with contractors, both good and bad, and offer advice on how to handle any issues that arise. This is a great resource for anyone in need of a contractor but unsure of who to hire.

Recommendations and Reviews

Redditors often ask for recommendations for specific services and receive helpful responses from other members. They can also share their own reviews of contractors and other services, giving others a heads up on what to expect.

General Information and Support

The Angie’s List subreddit is also a great place to find general information and support for any issues or questions you may have. Members are quick to offer their knowledge and experience to assist others in need.

Overall, if you’re looking for a community-driven forum to discuss Angie’s List and get opinions and advice, the subreddit is a great resource to turn to. Just keep in mind that the opinions and experiences shared are from individual members and should be taken with a grain of salt.

Is Angie’s List Expensive

If you are looking for reliable information about local businesses, Angie’s List and Yelp are two of the most popular options available. But some people wonder if Angie’s List is worth the price. In this section, we will explore the pricing structure of Angie’s List and whether it is expensive or not.

How Does Angie’s List Pricing Work

Angie’s List operates on a membership-based model. Users pay a fee to access the site’s content and reviews. As of 2021, Angie’s List offers two types of memberships: Green and Silver. The Green Membership is free and provides limited access to the site’s resources. The Silver Membership costs $24.99 per year and provides full access to all features and services, including customer support.

Is Angie’s List Worth the Price

The answer to this question depends on your needs and preferences. Angie’s List, unlike Yelp, focuses on high-quality service providers and businesses. The site’s reviews tend to be more detailed and informative, making it an excellent resource for people looking for reliable and trustworthy information. The site also allows you to contact service providers directly through the platform, making it easier to arrange appointments and receive quotes.

If you are someone who values quality over quantity and wants an ad-free experience, then Angie’s List might be worth the investment. The Silver Membership, at $24.99 per year, is relatively inexpensive compared to other similar services. Plus, the site offers a satisfaction guarantee, allowing users to receive a refund if they are unhappy with the service.

How Does Angie’s List Compare to Yelp

Both Angie’s List and Yelp offer similar services, but each site has its strengths and weaknesses. Yelp is free, making it accessible to everyone. However, Yelp’s reviews can be inconsistent, with some businesses receiving false or negative reviews. Additionally, Yelp’s advertising practices have come under fire, with some businesses accusing Yelp of extortion.

On the other hand, Angie’s List has a loyal user base that values the site’s verified and detailed reviews. The site’s strict verification process ensures that businesses cannot influence or manipulate their reviews. However, Angie’s List’s membership-based model can be a turnoff for some users.

Overall, whether Angie’s List is worth the price depends on your personal preferences and needs. If you value trustworthy, detailed, and verified reviews and are willing to pay a small fee, then Angie’s List might be the perfect service for you. However, if you don’t mind inconsistent reviews and prefer a free service, then Yelp might be a better fit.

Free Angie’s List Alternatives

If you are looking for a free alternative to Angie’s List, then you are in luck! There are several websites and apps that offer similar services without the costly subscriptions. Here are some of the best free alternatives to Angie’s List that you can try:

1. Yelp

Yelp is one of the most popular sites for finding and reviewing local businesses. It has a similar platform to Angie’s List, but it’s entirely free to use. Yelp offers user reviews, ratings, photos, and more information about businesses.

2. Nextdoor

Nextdoor is a social networking platform that connects neighbors and local communities. It’s an excellent place to find recommendations for local businesses from people in your area. You can also post your own reviews or ask for recommendations.

3. HomeAdvisor

HomeAdvisor is a website that connects homeowners to local service professionals. It offers free access to a network of trusted professionals, allowing homeowners to find and connect with local contractors, cleaners, and other service providers.

4. Thumbtack

Thumbtack is a platform that connects customers with local businesses. It’s entirely free to use, and you can get quotes from multiple professionals to compare. Thumbtack is an excellent platform for finding reliable contractors, cleaners, and other service providers.

5. Google Reviews

Google Reviews is another popular platform for finding and reviewing local businesses. It’s completely free to use and provides user reviews, ratings, and photos. You can also use it to search for businesses in your area and get directions.

In conclusion, there are several free alternatives to Angie’s List that you can use to find and review local businesses. Whether you prefer a social networking platform, a professional network, or a review site, there’s something for everyone. Try some of these platforms and see which one works best for you!

What is the Angie’s List Controversy

Angie’s List is a website where consumers can find and review local service providers. However, the site has been subject to controversy over the years. In this section, we’ll explore some of the most prominent controversies associated with the site.

Paid Memberships

One of the primary controversies surrounding Angie’s List is the fact that it’s a paid membership site. Consumers must pay a membership fee to access the site’s reviews and ratings. Critics argue that this creates a pay-to-play system that favors businesses that can afford to pay for better reviews.

Conflict of Interest

Angie’s List has also faced criticism over potential conflicts of interest. The site accepts advertising from service providers, which raises questions about the impartiality of its ratings and reviews. Some critics argue that the site’s business model creates a conflict of interest that undermines its credibility as a source of unbiased information.

Fake Reviews

Like other review sites, Angie’s List has had to contend with fake reviews. Some service providers have been accused of posting fake reviews to boost their ratings. Critics argue that the site’s review verification process isn’t robust enough to detect and remove fake reviews.


Angie’s List has been involved in several lawsuits over the years. In one case, the site was sued for allegedly manipulating reviews to make businesses appear more favorably. In another case, the site was sued for allegedly charging customers for memberships they didn’t sign up for.

In conclusion, Angie’s List is a popular website that has faced its fair share of controversy over the years. From paid memberships to potential conflicts of interest and fake reviews, the site has been subject to criticism from both consumers and critics. While the site can be a useful resource for finding local service providers, it’s important to consider the potential biases and limitations of its ratings and reviews.

Why is it no longer called Angie’s List

If you’ve been a user of Angie’s List for a while, you may have noticed that it’s not actually called Angie’s List anymore. So what happened?

A rebranding effort

In 2017, Angie’s List went through a rebranding effort and changed its name to “Angie’s List – Home Advisor”. This was done following the acquisition of Angie’s List by ANGI Homeservices, the parent company of HomeAdvisor.

The merger

The merger of Angie’s List and HomeAdvisor was seen as a strategic move to create a more comprehensive platform for home service professionals and homeowners. The merger allowed for a wider range of services to be offered to customers, from finding and booking a contractor to home maintenance and repair.

The benefits

The new name reflects the expanded services available on the platform. Users can now easily find professionals across a wider range of home services, including plumbing, landscaping, electrical services, and more. The merger also allows for improved convenience for customers, who can now access both services from a single platform.

What does this mean for users

The good news is that the merger has not changed the basic features of the platform. Users can still access valuable information on local contractors, read and leave reviews, and find tips and advice on home improvement projects. The rebranding simply reflects the evolution of the platform to provide more services and resources for homeowners.

In conclusion, Angie’s List has undergone a name change following a merger with HomeAdvisor, but the basic features and benefits of the platform remain largely unchanged. The rebranding reflects the platform’s expanded offerings and provides a one-stop-shop for home service needs.

Angie’s List vs HomeAdvisor vs Thumbtack

When it comes to finding trusted professionals for your home renovation or repair projects, Angie’s List, HomeAdvisor, and Thumbtack are three platforms that have earned a reputation as reliable and trustworthy sources. But what sets them apart from each other? Let’s take a closer look.

Angie’s List

Angie’s List is a subscription-based platform that started as a review site for home service professionals over two decades ago. Today, the platform is known for its verified user reviews and ratings, background-checked professionals, and fair price guarantee. Angie’s List also provides a massive collection of articles, tips, and buying guides to help homeowners make informed decisions.


HomeAdvisor, on the other hand, is a free-to-use platform that focuses mainly on connecting homeowners with prescreened and background-checked professionals. With HomeAdvisor, users can get quotes from multiple contractors, read reviews, and compare prices all in one place. Additionally, the platform offers a project cost guide, where users can estimate the cost of a project based on their zip code.


Thumbtack is a platform that focuses on small to medium-sized businesses and independent contractors. Unlike Angie’s List and HomeAdvisor, which connects you directly to the contractors, Thumbtack requires you to submit a project request and receive quotes from interested professionals. Thumbtack users can also browse profiles, read reviews, and ask the professionals questions before hiring them.

Which one to choose

While all three platforms have their unique features and benefits, choosing one over the others depends mainly on your needs, preferences, and budget. If you’re looking for verified and certified contractors and have an extensive project in mind, Angie’s List may be your best bet. If you’re looking for a free-to-use platform and would like to compare prices and choose from multiple quotes, HomeAdvisor may be the right choice for you. If you’re interested in hiring freelancers and small businesses for small to medium-sized projects, Thumbtack may be the platform you’ve been looking for.

In conclusion, each of these platforms can be an excellent resource for homeowners looking for trustworthy professionals to take on their project. It is essential to do your research and make an informed choice by considering the type of project, the budget, and the professionals’ qualifications.

Does Angie’s List have a good reputation

When it comes to finding quality services or businesses, one of the first platforms that many people flock to is Angie’s List. But, does Angie’s List have a good reputation? Let’s explore.

The Good

Angie’s List has been around since 1995 and has garnered a reputation for being one of the top review sites for home services. The website is user-friendly and allows potential customers to browse categories and read reviews before making a decision. One of the unique selling points of Angie’s List is that they have a strict review process that ensures credibility and accuracy. They use a verification process to ensure that all reviews are legitimate, and businesses cannot pay to be featured on the site.

The Bad

There have been some complaints about the high membership fees required to access Angie’s List. Some people have also reported that they felt pressured to upgrade their membership to access more information. Another downside is that Angie’s List is only available in certain locations, which limits its usefulness for individuals in smaller or rural areas.

The Ugly

Over the years, there have been a few controversies surrounding Angie’s List. In 2013, there was criticism that the company was suppressing negative reviews to keep advertisers happy. Additionally, the website has been accused of not being transparent about their membership costs and billing practices in the past. However, the company has made a concerted effort to address these issues and improve their reputation.

The Verdict

Despite some negative press, Angie’s List generally has a good reputation as a reliable platform for finding quality services. As with any review site, it’s essential to take individual reviews with a grain of salt and do additional research before making a final decision. However, the fact that Angie’s List has a strict verification process for reviews does lend credibility to the site’s overall reputation.

You May Also Like